Everyone’s Gone to the Movies – Summer Flix 2023

We are in the heart of summer movie season, so it seems like now would be a good time to take a quick peak at what’s going on this year.  It’s been a rough time for movies since the world has reopened following the worst of the pandemic. Two years of restrictions put people out of the habit of going to theaters routinely, and families seem willing to wait for movies to show up on streaming.

For example, Pixar’s Elemental had to worst opening weekend (adjusted for inflation) of any of the fabled animation studio’s features, bringing in a scant $29.5 million on a $200 million production budget. And while it’s reviews were decent, they were certainly more praise for competence than for over-the-top creativity.

DC’s (Warner Bros.) The Flash also opened weak with a weekend gross of $55 million and decidedly mediocre reviews.

There’s no question what is happening. The bigger issue is why?

There has been substantial speculation that Disney squandered a large portion of Pixar’s “specialness” by sending their last three movies (Soul, 2020; Luca, 2021; Turning Red, 2022) straight to Disney+ to help build subscriptions for their streaming service. And during the pandemic, that may have made sense. But it also taught audience members that Pixar films were really just home video content, not movies.

I also think that as Jessica Winter writes for The New Yorker that recent Pixar movies have been been much weaker than their earlier films, in part because of an outflow of talent. Dear Wife and I tried to watch 2022’s Lightyear, an origin story for the Buzz Lightyear toy from Toy Story, on Disney+ and bailed on it within 15 minutes. I found Luca slow going, despite having a Vespa scooter as a major story element. Turning Red was the only one of the recent Pixar releases to really impress me with a great story and fabulous animation.

The Flash has suffered from weak reviews both from critics and audience members. The DC Extended Universe has been in creative trouble since at least 2016, and the huge number of super hero movies has led to a level of fatigue with the genre. And the personal problems of star Ezra Miller certainly haven’t helped either.


This is not to say that the entire summer movie season is a bomb. Sony’s animated Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse tells a complex multi-verse story largely targeted at teens and adults and has been massively successful at the box office, bringing in more than $300 million in just over three weeks of release. It has also been a critical and artistic success,  getting a 96% on the Tomatometer and praise for both its storytelling and incredible animation.

Spider-Verse has had praise for its organic diversity — most obviously for having a Afro-Latino hero in teen-ager Miles Morales, but also for having the India-based Spider-guy Pavitr Prabhakar slinging webs around the incredible New York-Indian mashup of Mumbattan. And there is an understated support for trans-teens in the world inhabited by Gwen Stacy (Spider-Gwen) with a “Protect Trans Kids” flag in her room and her police officer dad wearing a trans flag on his uniform.

The major criticism the Spider-Verse sequel has had to face is that animators reportedly were working brutal hours completing the innovative film, and that a substantial number of animators left the studio over working conditions. Producer Amy Pascal has drawn fire for her comments dismissing the concerns of animators:


There is still a majority of the summer yet to come with highly anticipated blockbusters such as the final Indiana Jones movie and Christopher Nolan’s Oppenhiemer bio pic. (Dear Wife and I have had second-day IMAX tickets for Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny since the day they went on sale.) So we have yet to really see how willing audience members are to go to theaters, but there will certainly be a host of interesting things to see.


In closing, Dear Wife and I had a fantastic time Saturday afternoon going to see Buster Keaton silent short films with live piano accompaniment from pianist Rodney Sauer at our community-run World Theatre. The video below is of Sauer playing along with Harold Lloyd’s silent classic Safety Last on Friday evening .

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Everyone’s Gone to the Movies – Summer Flix 2023

Getting Started with Team Strange’s Wheels on Walls Grand Tour

Wheels on Walls Grand Tour For the last ten years or so, I’ve competed in a large-scale motorcycle scavenger hunt sponsored annually by Team Strange Airheads. This is a Twin Cities-based organization that got its start as a bowling team that evolved into a  BMW motorcycle club that now primarily sanctions a variety of short and longer-term motorcycle events.

This year’s even runs from April into November and is called “Wheels on Walls Grand Tour.” To get required 20 points, I need collect photos of my motorcycle and rally flag taken in front of outdoor murals. The primary goal is to get photos of murals featuring wheeled vehicles, for which I get two points for each.  I can also collect up to ten that don’t feature wheels in them for one points apiece. Finally, there are several “special” locations around the world – primarily in the US, Canada and Australia, that I could visit for larger numbers of points.

The winner of this year’s grand tour will get a lovely plaque and bragging rights for the year, and everyone who finishes will get an enameled pin. So as you can see, it’s all really about finding fun places to ride your motorcycle to.

Mary Jane Skala, an excellent reporter for our local newspaper, wrote a great story about my involvement over the years with Team Strange Grand Tours:

So, here are my initial photos collected so far this year. Many left to come:

May 6th – My first bonus location for the 2023 Team Strange Wheels on Walls Grand Tour. This roof mural honors the Southwest High School Rough Riders of Bartley, NE. (No-wheels photo #1)


May 25 - Shelton, NE, No Wheels #2

May 25th – Taken in Shelton, NE on my way up north to the Twin Cities. (No-wheels #2)

May 25 - A great railroad-themed mural from Central City, NE.

May 25 – A great railroad-themed mural from Central City, NE. Lots of wheels here.


May 27 - This series of three overhead door murals is part of an incredible collection of murals in a south St. Paul industrial and arts district. These three depict scenes in the history of the area and are on one of the buildings of the Can Can Wonderland Brewery.

May 27 – This series of three overhead door murals is part of an incredible collection of murals in a south St. Paul industrial and arts district. These three depict scenes in the history of the area and are on one of the buildings of the Can Can Wonderland entertainment complex.

May 27 - Another mural on a separate building that's part of the Can Can Wonderland complex in St. Paul, MN.

May 27 – Another mural on a separate building that’s part of the Can Can Wonderland complex in St. Paul, MN.

The rules of the Wheels on Walls only allow two murals per city, and since I already have two for St. Paul, I’m just posting this mural by Claudia Valentino and Dani Bianchini because it is so exciting and vibrant.


May 27 – Tree of Life on the New Brighton, MN civic building and county library. The way I see it, those “pinwheels” are delivering tree seeds out to the world. No one living around maple trees this spring could doubt that… (Will be interesting to see how TeamStrange Airheads refs judge it…) So, I hope this counts as a wheel post.

Posted in Motorcycling, Travel | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Getting Started with Team Strange’s Wheels on Walls Grand Tour

A Rough Week for Fox and its Hosts Part 2 – Bye Bye Tucker Carlson (& CNN’s Don Lemon)

The popular right-wing cable talk network Fox News has had a rough couple of weeks. In a previous post we talked about their settlement of Dominion Voting Systems $1.6 billion defamation suit. And in this post will discuss why popular Fox host Tucker Carlson was forced to leave (and how CNN may have used the Carlson news to bury their firing of Don Lemon).


On Monday, April 24, Fox News surprised the world by firing Tucker Carlson, the network’s (and cable TV’s) most popular talk show host. Technically, Fox and Carlson decided to “part ways,” but no one believes that Carlson left the right-wing talk network voluntarily.

Carlson had hosted his show on the previous Friday with no sign that he was going to be leaving the network. In fact, on the morning April 24 there had been a promo airing for his evening show. Washington Post media analyst Erik Wemple wrote that the fact that Carlson was not given a farewell episode meant that management didn’t trust him on the air.  This is in sharp contrast with how CNN handled the dismissal of their media critic Brian Stelter in 2022, who was given a final episode to say goodbye.

At the time of Carlson’s dismissal from Fox, there was a lot of speculation on why he was let go.

One theory is that it was the discovery materials from the Dominion lawsuit featuring sexist/racist messages from Carlson:

While there was speculation that Carlson’s negative messages about former President Donald Trump led to his dismissal, the Wall Street Journal suggested that it was Carlson’s negative messages about Fox management that did him in:

A few days after Carlson’s firing, the New York Times argued that it was a racist text message about “how white men fight” might have been the triggering cause, but lots of his critics note that Carlson routinely said things like that on his show.


Lost in the fog of gossip-worthy media has been the fact that CNN may well have used the timing of Carlson’s firing to minimize the news of their firing of long-time host Don Lemon for making sexist comments, including a disparaging remark that GOP presidential candidate Nikki Haley was “past her prime.” If so, it seems to have been largely successful. Though to be fair, Lemon’s firing really didn’t approach the level of Carlson’s:


 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on A Rough Week for Fox and its Hosts Part 2 – Bye Bye Tucker Carlson (& CNN’s Don Lemon)

The Second Annual(ish) Sehnert’s Bakery & Cafe Ride To Eat

There’s an old Harley rider catch phrase that says, “Live to Ride, Ride to Live.” Not a bad sentiment. But a bit general.

For members of the Iron Butt Association (which includes many Harley riders), there’s a more measurable version of the phrase which leads to a specific activity – Ride to Eat.  At its core, a Ride to Eat (or RTE) is a group of long-distance motorcycle riders getting together for meal and then turning around to head home afterwards.

So back in the summer of 2019 I hosted the inaugural Sehnert’s Bakery and Cafe Ride To Eat in McCook, Nebraska. The inspiration for this even was when Sehnert’s won a James Beard Classics award. The James Beard awards are essentially the Oscars of the restaurant and food business, and the classics award is for:

“Our nation’s beloved regional restaurants. Distinguished by their timeless appeal, they serve quality food that reflects the character of their communities. We anoint these locally owned restaurants with a James Beard Foundation Award and designate them as America’s Classics.”

Don’t the pastries at Sehnert’s look great? (Mike Konz photo)

The inaugural event was a great success with Iron Butt Rally finisher Bill Norris riding in from Texas just to have lunch and then turning around to ride straight back home to work an overnight shift. (See, I know my AP Style and that there is no such thing as a first annual event…) We also had riders from Kansas, South Dakota and Nebraska showing up at Sehnert’s for bierocs (also known as Runzas in Nebraska) or other excellent sandwiches.

The Second Annual McCook RTE was scheduled for May of 2020, but… we all know how that turned out!

It is now the spring of 2023, and if everything is not back to normal, whatever that is, motorcyclists are at least once again able to ride long distances to get together for lunch before heading back home.  So our gathering on Saturday, May 6th can’t really be called an annual event as there were three years and a global pandemic in between we’ll just call it the Second Annual(ish) McCook, NE Ride To Eat.

We had a beautiful day for riding Saturday with cool temps in the morning and bright sun the rest of the day. (Though a tornado and sever thunderstorms passed through our ride area not long after Mike Konz and I got home to Kearney.

There were six of us who gathered Saturday for coffee outside and then lunch inside the cafe. Iron Butt Rally finisher and winner of the 2023 Heart of Texas rally Paul Meyer rode in from Herrington, Kansas; and four-time IBR finisher Mike Riley rode in from Mustang, Oklahoma. Then from Nebraska, along with Mike Konz and myself from Kearney, were John Seberger from Lincoln, and John Koller, from Arapahoe. If there were an award for the shortest distance ridden J.K would have won, given that he lives just 40 miles away from McCook.

Kicking tires outside around the bikes is standard activity for our lunch crowd, including (l-r) Mike Riley, Paul Meyer, John Seberger, and yours truly – Ralph Hanson. (Mike Konz photo)

The six of us gathered for lunch included Paul Meyer, Mike Riley, John Seberger, John Koller, Ralph Hanson (me), and Mike Konz. Interesting that two-thirds of our group had shared names. 

This is the route Mike K. and I followed to and from McCook, NE. A great day of riding followed by heavy weather not long after we arrived back at home.

At any rate, we all had a great time and hope that the actual Third Annual McCook RTE will be able to happen in May of 2024 without any difficulties!


Meanwhile, on this trip I also got the first photo of a building mural for my Team Strange 2023 Grand Tour. Always great to get the first photo in the bank. This roof mural honors the Southwest High School Rough Riders of Bartley, NE.

My first bonus location for the 2023 Team Strange Wheels on Walls Grand Tour. The real goal is to have murals with wheeled-vehicles on them, but you are allowed a limited number of non-wheeled murals. This is one of them. (Mike Konz photo)

 

Posted in Motorcycling | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on The Second Annual(ish) Sehnert’s Bakery & Cafe Ride To Eat

A Rough Week for Fox and its Hosts Part I – Dominion Voting Settlement

The popular right-wing cable talk network Fox News has had a rough couple of weeks. Today, we’ll talk about their settlement of Dominion Voting Systems $1.6 billion defamation suit. And in our next post will discuss why popular Fox host Tucker Carlson was forced to leave.


The Fox News network announced a settlement Tuesday, April 18, with Dominion Voting System’s libel lawsuit that claimed that Dominion was defamed by Fox’s false claims that the company helped rig the 2020 presidential election against Donald Trump. There was never any evidence that this happened. Fox agreed to pay $787.5 million to the voting equipment company to bring the lawsuit to a close. According to The Washington Post, this was the “largest publicly disclosed monetary settlement ever in an American defamation action.”

While Dominion got a massive financial settlement, they did not get a substantial apology from Fox. Instead, the network issued a statement that said, “We acknowledge the Court’s rulings finding certain claims about Dominion to be false.”

The settlement was announced two days into what was to be the start of the trial. Numerous people critical of Fox were unhappy that Fox did not give a meaningful apology. But it’s worth remembering that this was Dominion’s lawsuit, and by settling they got a guaranteed large financial settlement without an extended trial.

Washington Post media commentator Erik Wemple notes that Dominion had massive amounts of evidence they said showed that Fox knew the claims made by Trump and his supporters about Dominion were false, and that the claims were being broadcast to help keep Fox’s audience happy.

Journalist Charles Fishman had an excellent Twitter thread last week where he explained why it made good sense for Dominion to settle without a trial. His key points included:

  • There would be no audio or video from the trial to highlight the lies Fox hosts propagated.
  • There would not be great social media materials to go viral.
  • There was a good chance that it would take years for a court case to settle.
  • A cash settlement now would give Dominion 80 times its annual profit with a single check.
  • The only thing Dominion is not getting is a clear apology from Fox.

Would you settle under these circumstances?


Settling would also seem to be in Fox’s best interests. Wemple, writing the day before the case settled, gave multiple reasons why Fox News would want to avoid going to trial. These include:

  • The trial would be a public relations disaster for the network. Every day of coverage of the lead-up to the trial included more dirt on the company coming from e-mails and texts from inside the company.
  • The judge was not sympathetic to Fox’s arguments. He was continually criticizing their attorneys’ behavior.
  • Fox winning in court could result in the Supreme Court changing the long-standing “actual malice” standard for public officials to prove libel. Several members of the court have indicated that they would be interested in reconsidering that standard, making it much easier for public officials to sue for libel. That kind of decision would clearly not be in Fox’s best interests. (Or, to be honest, that of any news company.)

Up Next:  Why Fox fired popular host Tucker Carlson.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on A Rough Week for Fox and its Hosts Part I – Dominion Voting Settlement

Current Problems with Sports News, Social Media, and AI-Generated Images

There’s a lot of important journalism to be done surrounding professional sports. But when the leagues own the media outlets covering them, there’s a real limit to how far the reporters can go. This situation, with the NFL owning a network, ranks up there with the problems created years ago with ESPN sucking up to the leagues so they wouldn’t lose the cable rights. For example: How ESPN and the NBA handled fights over civil rights in Hong Kong and China.


Saw great comment that Elon Musk is running Twitter into the ground in the manner of a cartoonish “chaotic evil” villain. Thoughtful analysis of the tech billionaire’s mismanagement of the bird site.


Talk about AI-generated images have been everywhere as of late, including concerns about  intellectual property of artists whose images are being modeled, the need to support human artists (my Twitter avatar was drawn by graphic designer/web comic artist Gordon McAlpin and my Zoom avatar created by graphic novelist Sophie Goldstein), and the emerging problems of deep-fake deceptions.


And finally, some disturbed person put together a Banshees of Inisherin video game!  Colm has to go through a Pac-Man-like maze trying to collect his severed fingers on the way to the pub before being caught one of his annoying pursuers.   (You may remember that Banshees was my “most memorable” movie of 2022.)


Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Current Problems with Sports News, Social Media, and AI-Generated Images

A Global Tour of Government Officials Attacking Press Freedom

One of the most depressing things showing up in my Twitter feed over the last week or so has been the number of cases of journalists and news outlets being under attack around the world and here in the United States. Here are several examples.


Journalism is under attack in Bangladesh.


And similar attacks by the government are happening in nearby India.


Over in Pakistan (and elsewhere around the world), women journalists are being attacked online simply for being women.


Over in Russia, journalists are needing help being smuggled out of the country.


Cambodia’s prime minister is shutting down local news organizations.


And Florida’s Ron DeSantis wants to roll back press freedom in the United States.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/10/us/politics/ron-desantis-news-media.html

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on A Global Tour of Government Officials Attacking Press Freedom

A triangle of everything I have to say about the Oscar’s screaming banshees….

Really pleased by this year’s Oscar nominees, having been to a surprising number of the nominated films. But what I’m most excited about is seeing some excellent “small” movies getting nominated for Best Picture and a bunch of other major awards.

It’s so great to see movies like The Banshees of Inisherin, Everything Everywhere All at Once, and The Triangle of Sadness getting nominated for Best Picture as well as other awards.(Everything Everywhere topped the list of nominations with 11!)

I’m perfectly happy to see them joined by crowd pleasers such as Elvis, Avatar: The Way of Water and Top Gun: Maverick. Those three blockbusters all helped remind lots of people how enjoyable it can be to go see a big movie on the big screen. I watched and enjoyed all of them. Of the blockbusters, the Avatar sequel was my favorite, well worth driving to the city to see it in 3D on the big screen with top-notch sound.

But I hope that the nominations will help bring more people to watch some of these quirkier, smaller movies as well.


I’ve previously written about The Banshees of Inisherin as being the most interesting or memorable movie I’ve seen this year. 

Poster for Banshees of Inisherin featuring Bolin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson.

This little film, staring Colin Farrell, Brendan Gleeson, Kerry Condon and Barry Keoghan, tells the story of two old friends living on a remote Irish island in the 1920s when Gleeson’s character decides he doesn’t want to spend anymore of his limited life with Farrell’s character.

I was fortunate enough to see this at our gem of a community-run non-profit The World Theatre. And this is a movie that demands your full attention in a darkened room with no distractions from phones or other electronics. It is billed as a dark comedy, and I suppose it is that. But mostly it is a story of what a friendship can mean and how we decide to spend our time on earth.

It’s great to see the entire leading cast nominated for acting awards, including Farrell for Best Actor, Gleeson and Barry Keoghan for Best Supporting Actor, and Kerry Condon for Best Supporting Actress. And when you combine that with a Best Original Screenplay nod, it’s not hard to see what makes this movie so good – a great script and great actors to perform them.


 

I also really enjoyed the rather strange Triangle of Sadness.
Triangle of Sadness movie poster.

It’s an excellent look at the power in our relationships, and how that power can change as our circumstances change. Triangle considers the relationships between men and women, the rich & beautiful and those who serve them, capitalists and Marxists, and those with survival skills and those who are suddenly worthless. I know this doesn’t sound fun and exciting, but I highly recommend it if you can get past the amount of rather comical vomiting during a storm at sea. I doubt it will pick up any wins, but I would love for more people to see and talk about this provocative film.


Everything Everywhere All at Once is the most familiar and successful of these smaller films, and it takes the multiverse concepts so overblown in Marvel movies and applies them to perfectly ordinary people trying to get through their life issues like running a small business, maintaining relationships, and making sense out of craziness. (Yes, for the record, I loved Dr. Strange and the Multiverse of Madness.) Like Banshees, almost all of the lead performers get nominations, including Best Actress Michelle Yeoh, who shows her dramatic, comedic and action chops all out in equal measure; Jamie Lee Curtis and Stephanie Hsu for Best Supporting Actress; and Ke Huy Quan (who you may remember as a child star from Goonies and Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom) for Best Supporting Actor. (Quan also is making an incredible comeback after staying away from acting for about 20 years.)
Everything Everywhere All at Once poster.


By all means, go see the blockbusters, but also make sure you get to see the smaller films as well. (I still have yet to see Spielberg’s The Fablemans, but I hope to remedy that before Oscar night.)


And finally, Michelle Yeoh is the first Asian Best Actress nominee. Or at least the first who acknowledges her Asian heritage. There’s been a little controversy over a story from the Hollywood Reporter today mentioning that Yeoh is the first Best Actress nominee who identifies as Asian. That’s not as snarky as it sounds, because the have likely been Asian nominees in the past, most notably Merle Oberon who passed for white and hid the fact that her mother was of partial Sri Lankan descent.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on A triangle of everything I have to say about the Oscar’s screaming banshees….

Twits commenting on AI student deception, auto transcription & more charges of bias

Twitter’s had a lot of discussion about some interesting issues in the last week. Here’s some thoughts on student use of AI tools, use of automated transcription, and false equivalency bias.


Yes. There are lots of ways that students can deceive faculty. New technology like the AI writing and art tools can certainly do so. But so can girl/boyfriends, greek system archives, and purchased help. The real solution is to know your student’s writing style (which really only occurs in upper-division classes) so you can tell when it wasn’t written by them.


There are a lot of tools out there to automate interview transcription. But as the author of this list points out, there can also be real privacy concerns about what the transcription services do with their data (your data that’s become theirs). Also, there is a lot to be said for transcribing the recordings yourself – that’s how you really get to know what’s in the interview. But, I understand, there isn’t always time for that.


Journalists are terrified of being accused of being biased. We need to get over it. No matter what we do, we will be accused of being biased. But here’s the truth – both sides are not always (perhaps only rarely) equivalent. In the case of the debt limit – one side wants to have a clean raise of the debt limit. One side wants to threaten to crash through it. (To be fair, if the Democrats had been serious about really wanting to make the problem go away, they could have done so, or at least tried to do so, during the lame duck session.)

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Comments Off on Twits commenting on AI student deception, auto transcription & more charges of bias

Will we be extremists for love or hate? Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr’s Letter from a Birmingham Jail

" One of the greatest honors of my life was being invited to speak at the Martin Luther King, Jr. candlelight vigil several years ago at the UNK student union, along with KevinThe question is not whether we will be extremists, but what kind of extremists we will be. Will we be extremists for hate or for love? Will we be extremists for the preservation of injustice or for the extension of justice?... The nation and the world are in dire need of creative extremists." Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr National Museum of African American History & Culture

One of the greatest honors of my life was being invited to speak at the Martin Luther King, Jr. candlelight vigil several years ago at the UNK student union, along with Kevin Chaney, who was then UNK’s women’s basketball coach. 

Here’s what I had to say about Dr. King when I spoke:

Visalli-11-10-13When we think of public relations, we think of a professional in a suit trying to persuade us about something related to a large corporation. But not all PR is practiced by big business.

Civil rights leader The Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. had a brilliant understanding of public relations during the campaign to desegregate Birmingham, Alabama in 1963.

The goal of the campaign was to have non-violent demonstrations and resistance to force segregated businesses to open up to African Americans. What King, and the members of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, wanted to do was stage a highly visible demonstration that would not only force change in Birmingham, but also grab the attention of the entire American public.

King and his colleagues picked Birmingham because it was one of he most segregated cities in America and because it had Eugene “Bull” Conner as police commissioner.

Conner was a racist who could be counted on to attack the peaceful marchers. Birmingham was a city where black protestors were thrown in jail, and the racists were bombing homes and churches. There was a black neighborhood that had so many bombings it came to be known as Dynamite Hill.

Dr. King and his colleagues had planned demonstrations and boycotts in Birmingham, but held off with them in order to let the political system and negotiations work. But time passed, and nothing changed. Signs were still up at the lunch counters and water fountains, and protestors were still headed to jail.

King and the rest of the SCLC needed to get attention for the plight of African Americans in cities like Birmingham.

They needed to do more than fight back against the racism of segregation. They needed to get Americans of good will in all the churches and synagogues to hear their voices.

Starting in April of 1963, predominantly African American volunteers would march in the streets, hold sit-ins at segregated lunch counters, and boycott local businesses in Birmingham. As the protests started, so did the arrests.

On Good Friday, King and Abernathy joined in the marching so that they would be arrested. While King was in jail, he was given a copy of the Birmingham News, in which there was an article where white Alabama clergy urged the SCLC to stop the demonstrations and boycotts and allow the courts to solve the problem of segregation.

But King was tired of waiting, and so he wrote what would become one of the great statements of the civil rights cause. One that spoke to people who were fundamentally their friends, not their enemies. This came to be known as the “Letter from a Birmingham Jail.

Writing the letter was not easy. Dr. King wrote it in the margins of the newspaper. He wrote it on scraps of note paper. He wrote it on panels of toilet paper. (Think about what the toilet paper was like if Dr. King was able to write on it!)

The letter spoke to the moderates who were urging restraint. To them, he wrote:

“My Dear Fellow Clergymen:

While confined here in the Birmingham city jail, I came across your recent statement calling my present activities “unwise and untimely.” Seldom do I pause to answer criticism of my work and ideas…. But since I feel that you are men of genuine good will and that your criticisms are sincerely set forth, I want to try to answer your statement in what I hope will be patient and reasonable terms.”

He went on the acknowledge that perhaps he was an extremist, but that he was an extremist for love, not for hate:

“But though I was initially disappointed at being categorized as an extremist, as I continued to think about the matter I gradually gained a measure of satisfaction from the label.

Was not Jesus an extremist for love: “Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you.”

Was not Amos an extremist for justice: “Let justice roll down like waters and righteousness like an ever flowing stream.” …

Was not Martin Luther an extremist: “Here I stand; I cannot do otherwise, so help me God.” …

And Abraham Lincoln: “This nation cannot survive half slave and half free.”

And Thomas Jefferson: “We hold these truths to be self evident, that all men are created equal . . .”

So the question is not whether we will be extremists, but what kind of extremists we will be. Will we be extremists for hate or for love?”

King’s jailhouse writings were smuggled out and published as a brochure. His eloquent words were given added force for being written in jail. As he says toward the end of his letter, it is very different to send a message from jail than from a hotel room:

“Never before have I written so long a letter. I’m afraid it is much too long to take your precious time. I can assure you that it would have been much shorter if I had been writing from a comfortable desk, but what else can one do when he is alone in a narrow jail cell, other than write long letters, think long thoughts and pray long prayers?”

Once King was released from jail eight days later, he and his followers raised the stakes. No longer would adults be marching and being arrested, children would become the vanguard. And as the children marched, photographers and reporters from around the world would document these young people being attacked by dogs, battered by water from fire hoses, and filling up the Birmingham jails.

King faced criticism for allowing the young people to face the dangers of marching in Birmingham. But he responded by criticizing the white press, asking the reporters where they had been “during the centuries when our segregated social system had been misusing and abusing Negro children.”

Although there was rioting in Birmingham, and King’s brother’s house was bombed, the campaign was ultimately successful. Business owners took down the signs that said “WHITE” and “COLORED” from the drinking fountains and bathrooms, and anyone was allowed to eat at the lunch counters. The successful protest in Birmingham set the stage for the March on Washington that would take place in August of 1963, where King would give his famous “I have a dream” speech.

We are now more than fifty years from King’s letter from Birmingham Jail. This letter was not one of his “feel good” speeches. It doesn’t raise the spirit the way his “I have a dream” speech did.

But it did give us a message that still matters more than ever today:

 “I hope this letter finds you strong in the faith. I also hope that circumstances will soon make it possible for me to meet each of you, not as an integrationist or a civil-rights leader but as a fellow clergyman and a Christian brother. Let us all hope that the dark clouds of racial prejudice will soon pass away and the deep fog of misunderstanding will be lifted from our fear drenched communities, and in some not too distant tomorrow the radiant stars of love and brotherhood will shine over our great nation with all their scintillating beauty.”

Posted in Chapter 13 | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Will we be extremists for love or hate? Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr’s Letter from a Birmingham Jail