Will we be extremists for love or hate? Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr’s Letter from a Birmingham Jail

" One of the greatest honors of my life was being invited to speak at the Martin Luther King, Jr. candlelight vigil several years ago at the UNK student union, along with KevinThe question is not whether we will be extremists, but what kind of extremists we will be. Will we be extremists for hate or for love? Will we be extremists for the preservation of injustice or for the extension of justice?... The nation and the world are in dire need of creative extremists." Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr National Museum of African American History & Culture

One of the greatest honors of my life was being invited to speak at the Martin Luther King, Jr. candlelight vigil several years ago at the UNK student union, along with Kevin Chaney, who was then UNK’s women’s basketball coach. 

Here’s what I had to say about Dr. King when I spoke:

Visalli-11-10-13When we think of public relations, we think of a professional in a suit trying to persuade us about something related to a large corporation. But not all PR is practiced by big business.

Civil rights leader The Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. had a brilliant understanding of public relations during the campaign to desegregate Birmingham, Alabama in 1963.

The goal of the campaign was to have non-violent demonstrations and resistance to force segregated businesses to open up to African Americans. What King, and the members of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, wanted to do was stage a highly visible demonstration that would not only force change in Birmingham, but also grab the attention of the entire American public.

King and his colleagues picked Birmingham because it was one of he most segregated cities in America and because it had Eugene “Bull” Conner as police commissioner.

Conner was a racist who could be counted on to attack the peaceful marchers. Birmingham was a city where black protestors were thrown in jail, and the racists were bombing homes and churches. There was a black neighborhood that had so many bombings it came to be known as Dynamite Hill.

Dr. King and his colleagues had planned demonstrations and boycotts in Birmingham, but held off with them in order to let the political system and negotiations work. But time passed, and nothing changed. Signs were still up at the lunch counters and water fountains, and protestors were still headed to jail.

King and the rest of the SCLC needed to get attention for the plight of African Americans in cities like Birmingham.

They needed to do more than fight back against the racism of segregation. They needed to get Americans of good will in all the churches and synagogues to hear their voices.

Starting in April of 1963, predominantly African American volunteers would march in the streets, hold sit-ins at segregated lunch counters, and boycott local businesses in Birmingham. As the protests started, so did the arrests.

On Good Friday, King and Abernathy joined in the marching so that they would be arrested. While King was in jail, he was given a copy of the Birmingham News, in which there was an article where white Alabama clergy urged the SCLC to stop the demonstrations and boycotts and allow the courts to solve the problem of segregation.

But King was tired of waiting, and so he wrote what would become one of the great statements of the civil rights cause. One that spoke to people who were fundamentally their friends, not their enemies. This came to be known as the “Letter from a Birmingham Jail.

Writing the letter was not easy. Dr. King wrote it in the margins of the newspaper. He wrote it on scraps of note paper. He wrote it on panels of toilet paper. (Think about what the toilet paper was like if Dr. King was able to write on it!)

The letter spoke to the moderates who were urging restraint. To them, he wrote:

“My Dear Fellow Clergymen:

While confined here in the Birmingham city jail, I came across your recent statement calling my present activities “unwise and untimely.” Seldom do I pause to answer criticism of my work and ideas…. But since I feel that you are men of genuine good will and that your criticisms are sincerely set forth, I want to try to answer your statement in what I hope will be patient and reasonable terms.”

He went on the acknowledge that perhaps he was an extremist, but that he was an extremist for love, not for hate:

“But though I was initially disappointed at being categorized as an extremist, as I continued to think about the matter I gradually gained a measure of satisfaction from the label.

Was not Jesus an extremist for love: “Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you.”

Was not Amos an extremist for justice: “Let justice roll down like waters and righteousness like an ever flowing stream.” …

Was not Martin Luther an extremist: “Here I stand; I cannot do otherwise, so help me God.” …

And Abraham Lincoln: “This nation cannot survive half slave and half free.”

And Thomas Jefferson: “We hold these truths to be self evident, that all men are created equal . . .”

So the question is not whether we will be extremists, but what kind of extremists we will be. Will we be extremists for hate or for love?”

King’s jailhouse writings were smuggled out and published as a brochure. His eloquent words were given added force for being written in jail. As he says toward the end of his letter, it is very different to send a message from jail than from a hotel room:

“Never before have I written so long a letter. I’m afraid it is much too long to take your precious time. I can assure you that it would have been much shorter if I had been writing from a comfortable desk, but what else can one do when he is alone in a narrow jail cell, other than write long letters, think long thoughts and pray long prayers?”

Once King was released from jail eight days later, he and his followers raised the stakes. No longer would adults be marching and being arrested, children would become the vanguard. And as the children marched, photographers and reporters from around the world would document these young people being attacked by dogs, battered by water from fire hoses, and filling up the Birmingham jails.

King faced criticism for allowing the young people to face the dangers of marching in Birmingham. But he responded by criticizing the white press, asking the reporters where they had been “during the centuries when our segregated social system had been misusing and abusing Negro children.”

Although there was rioting in Birmingham, and King’s brother’s house was bombed, the campaign was ultimately successful. Business owners took down the signs that said “WHITE” and “COLORED” from the drinking fountains and bathrooms, and anyone was allowed to eat at the lunch counters. The successful protest in Birmingham set the stage for the March on Washington that would take place in August of 1963, where King would give his famous “I have a dream” speech.

We are now more than fifty years from King’s letter from Birmingham Jail. This letter was not one of his “feel good” speeches. It doesn’t raise the spirit the way his “I have a dream” speech did.

But it did give us a message that still matters more than ever today:

 “I hope this letter finds you strong in the faith. I also hope that circumstances will soon make it possible for me to meet each of you, not as an integrationist or a civil-rights leader but as a fellow clergyman and a Christian brother. Let us all hope that the dark clouds of racial prejudice will soon pass away and the deep fog of misunderstanding will be lifted from our fear drenched communities, and in some not too distant tomorrow the radiant stars of love and brotherhood will shine over our great nation with all their scintillating beauty.”

Posted in Chapter 13 | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Will we be extremists for love or hate? Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr’s Letter from a Birmingham Jail

Set Free The C-SPAN!

Kevin McCarthy on C-SPAN

Rep. Kevin McCarthy on C-SPAN during the multiple votes for Speaker of the House.


If you’ve been watching the Kevin McCarthy for Speaker mess over in the U.S. House of Representatives on C-SPAN (and who among us hasn’t been riveted on C-SPAN that last four days?), you can’t help but notice that the video has been much more engaging than their typical coverage of the house.

Part of that is certainly because what could be more exciting than a once-in-a-century struggle of the majority party to elect a speaker and start the session of Congress?

But the real reason is closely related.

Under normal circumstances, the Speaker of the House sets the rules for how the cameras can be used for C-SPAN broadcasts. But since there currently isn’t a speaker, the C-SPAN camera operators and directors can focus on whatever they want to, which means we can see all the groups of people getting together to negotiate, commiserate, or just congregate on the house floor.

We’ve seen some amazing things here.

Consider this conversation between Freedom Caucus Republican Paul Gossar and Squad-member Democrat Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC). What makes this particularly interesting is that Gossar had previously posted a social media video that had a cartoon version of himself murdering a cartoon AOC.

Another favorite of mine was the arial look down at Congress that echos the view of the Library of Congress from the movie All The President’s Men.

But, really, it’s just the amazing looks at the House in action.



Perhaps the greatest moment of coverage came Thursday night when the whole House gave a standing ovation to Clerk of the House Cheryl Johnson, who is running things absent absent a speaker.


Seriously, whoever is elected Speaker, please set free C-SPAN to be it’s best self!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Set Free The C-SPAN!

2022 in Review – Ralph’s favorite and most memorable books, movies, music, video games & TV shows

I don’t know that I believe in a Best Of Annual Review, but here’s a list of what I enjoyed in media during 2022.


Favorite Audio Book/Book Series:
Andy Serkis reading The Hobbit Lord of the Rings

Cover of Lord of the Rings audiobook read by Andy Serkis.J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings have been favorites of mine since my teens. I loved the books, and I really enjoyed the Peter Jackson LOTR movies (though the less said about his Hobbit movies, the better). But I think this very long tale has found it’s ultimate expression with actor Andy Serkis’ new audiobook recording of the entire series. Although it was just Serkis reading, he has such talent as a voice actor it’s as though it were a fully cast recording.

Tolkien writes that the whole point of LOTR was to tell a really long tale, and if you are reading it in print, it is all too easy to skip over some of the songs or poetry or history. But these are all part of telling a long tale in its fullness. And with Serkis reading/singing/reciting it, there is little temptation to bypass the slower portions (don’t say boring parts…)


Favorite Print Book:
Ducks: Two Years in the Oil Sands, by Kate Beaton

Ducks: Two Years in the Oil Sands is not only my favorite graphic novel of the year but my favorite print book. (I do most of my recreational reading with audiobooks.) Before Ducks, Nova Scotian Kate Beaton was best known for her long-running Hark a Vagrant webcomics and anthologies that skewer everything from super heroes to Victorian literature to Canadian history.

In Ducks, Beaton tells of the two years she spend back in the 2000s working in the Alberta oil sands as a way of paying off her school debt for a degree in the humanities. Working out west was a massive change for her – leaving behind the remote life in Cape Breton Nova Scotia where family and friends lived but there were few good-paying jobs. The oil fields were far from Nova Scotia, were full of men who were far from home, and was where women were massively outnumbered.

Beaton’s story is full of her characteristic humor and skewed observations, but it is also a painful narrative of sexual harassment and assault. The comics manage to capture the young men, barely out of boyhood, seeking some kind of adventure; the older men, trying to support themselves and their far-away families; and the young women, desperate for good-paying work.

The book has made a number of top book lists of 2022, most notably former President Barak Obama’s.

Page from Ducks: Two Years in the Oil Sands by Kate BeatonThe pages from this graphic novel are not just traditional comic panels. Some are much larger scale that capture the remote, desolate, and sometimes beautiful settings of Beaton’s work in the oil fields, such as this one illustrating the northern lights.

Art from Ducks by Kate Beaton depicting northern lights.


Most Memorable Movie of the Year:
The Banshees of Inisherin

Please note that this is my most memorable movie, as in the movie I can’t stop thinking about, not my favorite movie of the year.

This little film, staring Colin Farrell, Brendan Gleeson, Kerry Condon and Barry Keoghan, tells the story of two old friends living on a remote Irish island in the 1920s when Gleeson’s character decides he doesn’t want to spend anymore of his limited life with Farrell’s character.

I was fortunate enough to see this at our gem of a community-run non-profit The World Theatre. And this is a movie that demands your full attention in a darkened room with no distractions from phones or other electronics. It is billed as a dark comedy, and I suppose it is that. But mostly it is a story of what a friendship can mean and how we decide to spend our time on earth.

I would urge you not to find out anything more about this odd little movie. And if you have access to subtitles while you watch it, you might avail yourself. The accents get a bit thick. Currently streaming on HBO Max.


Favorite Movie of the Year:
Tick, Tick … BOOM!

Actually a 2021 movie, but I saw it on the big screen at The World Theatre early in 2022 and twice more on streaming later on. Since this is the only movie I watched three times in 2022, it has to be my favorite, No?

Tick, Tick … BOOM! is Jonathan Larson’s (of RENT fame) first produced musical, and it tells the story of how he tried unsuccessfully to get a show based loosely on 1984 produced. Lin-Manuel Miranda directed and Andrew Garfield stars in this uplifting and tear-jerking story of Larson facing turning 30 without being as successful of a composer as Stephen Sondheim. So many great songs, such a talented cast, so many amazing cameos. This may be heresy, but I like the movie version of TTB! even better than RENT.

Only available on Netflix.


Favorite Old Movie of the Year:
In a Lonely Place

From 1950, In a Lonely Place is a top-notch film noir directed by Nicholas Ray that was new to my Dear Wife and me this year. It was featured on Turner Classic Movie’s Noir Alley series, hosted by Eddie Muller. It stars Humphrey Bogart as a failing Hollywood screenwriter and Gloria Grahame as a new love interest who has to come to terms with suspicions that Bogart’s character has murdered the last woman he was with.

A wonderfully complex story of existentialism, trust, and temper, it’s available in a variety of formats (see the link above) but will certainly show up sooner or later again on TCM. Don’t miss it when it does. Bogart is good in almost everything he does (even the silly The Return of Dr. X), but Lonely Place has to be one of his best dramatic performances.


Favorite Music of the Year
Bach’s Six Unaccompanied Cello Suites, performed by Yo-Yo Ma, Jan Vogler, and Pablo Casals. 

Apple Music’s Replay statistics for 2022 suggest that I spent close to 5,000 minutes (83 hours) listening to the Bach Unaccompanied Cello suites from various recordings over 2022. The six suites combined run about two-and-a-half hours if played without interruption. I won’t pretend to be able to explain why they matter or are so important. I only know that every time I listen to them, there is something new to pull from them. My listening included three different complete recordings of the suites from Yo-Yo Ma, one from Austrian cellist Jan Vogler, and the original recordings of the suites by Spanish cellist Pablo Casals from the late 1930s that reintroduced the suites to the world after they had been largely ignored for nearly 200 years.

Here’s Ma performing the six suites for the BBC Proms 2015.

Image of Yo-Yo Ma playing the Bach cello suites with link to YouTube video


Favorite Video Game of the Year
Pure Mahjong

This was a tough one to decide on. But I suppose the measure of my favorite game was the one I spent the most time playing – and that would be Pure Mahjong for the Nintendo Switch. It is a simple Mahjong game that offers four boards each day, ranging from easy to challenging. All of them have the advantage of being doable if played correctly. I often finish the evening by working my way through three or all four boards before bed. They are an excellent way of clearing my head of whatever else has been afflicting it. I have had a version of Mahjong (or Shanghai) on almost every video game system I’ve owned over the years, and they have always been an enjoyable stress reliever. But this version with four new boards every day is the best. It is available for $2.99 (through 1/13/23) as a digital download from Nintendo.com.

Pure Mahjong screenshot for Nintendo Switch


Favorite TV Series:
Jeopardy!

In the spring of 2019, the year before the COVID19 pandemic really took hold, my family got in the habit of watching Jeopardy! every evening at dinnertime as professional gambler James Holzhauer began transforming the game with his aggressive play. (Spare me the judgey-ness on watching TV with dinner. You know you do it!)

Since then, whenever Jeopardy! is not in reruns, Dear Wife and I are regular viewers, shouting out our answers and competing fiercely with each other. We have watched our way through a number of “super champions” who are able to utilize Holzhauer’s strategies to build amazing winning streaks.

I think what attracts us most to Jeopardy is that it celebrates people who are smart and well read. What more could you ask for in a competition show?

Co-host Ken Jennings remembers Alex Trebek

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Comments Off on 2022 in Review – Ralph’s favorite and most memorable books, movies, music, video games & TV shows

We’re back! A Year In Movies 2021 – Part 10

In December of 2020, when it became clear we were not going to be returning to normal life any time soon, we purchased a big honking 55-inch 4K TV and settled in for a year of watching movies at home. By Dec. 31, 2021, we had watched 236 movies either together or separately. This is one of series of blog posts about those films.

It’s been several months since I last posted to this series – I hope to be more regular with it in the months to come. But we return with a vintage Sherlock Holmes story, a documentary, and a couple thrillers from the latter portion of the 20th Century.


 

#33 – The Woman in Green, Sherlock Holmes (1945), directed by Roy William Neill; starring Basil Rathbone, Nigel Bruce and Hillary Brooke. Rathbone made 14 Sherlock Holmes movies, his most prominent character in more than 70 films. This one was based on a pair of Arthur Conan Doyle stories: The Adventures of the Empty House and The Final Problem. 


#34 – Hearts of Darkness (1991), directed by Fax Bahr, George Hickenlooper, & Eleanor Coppola, starring just about everyone involved with making Francis Ford Coppola’s Apocalypse Now, an adaptation of Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness. 

This is a documentary on the brilliant madness that was the filming of Apocalypse Now, including a typhoon, star Martin Sheen’s heart attack during the filming, and a script that never seemed to never be complete. The core of the film is based on behind-the-scenes footage shot by Eleanor Coppola, Francis’s wife. Hickenlooper and Bahr then edited that footage with new interviews to create the documentary. Highly recommend this for you after you’ve seen Apocalypse Now. I purchased my copy of this as part of a two-movie package from Apple with the latest cut of Apocalypse Now.


#35 – Avalanche (1979), directed by Corey Allen, starring Rock Hudson and Mia Farrow. An utterly unmemorable film produced by low-budget movie king Roger Corman about an avalanche at a ski resort.


#36 – Midnight Run (1988), directed by Martin Brest, staring Robert De Niro, Charles Grodin, and Yaphet Kotto. A fantastic road trip thriller starring De Niro as a bounty hunter bringing in a mob accountant played by Grodin. Kotto is the FBI agent chasing both of them. The less you know about the film beyond this, the better. One of the great entertaining movies of the 1980s.


Coming up next: The movie that led to Bewitched along with one of the most successful movies of all time.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Comments Off on We’re back! A Year In Movies 2021 – Part 10

99 Great Kids’ Books From the WaPo

Going to take the lazy way out on this and just put up the Twitter thread….


Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Comments Off on 99 Great Kids’ Books From the WaPo

I am thankful…

I posted the following on my Facebook page over the Thanksgiving holiday. Since I asked my students to do a Thanksgiving post, I thought I would do one, too.


Dad playing Scrabble.

So much to be thankful for this year! I am:

  • Thankful for playing Scrabble with my 95-year-old dad Wednesday evening.
  • Thankful for my Dear Wife, who is always so supportive of me and my travels. (And who insisted I go visit Dad for Thanksgiving.)
  • Thankful for my wonderful sons, daughters-in-law, and grandchildren, born and soon-to-be born.
  • Thankful for an extended family whom I always look forward to spending time with.
  • Thankful for my Dear Wife’s extended family who are caring and supportive.
  • Thankful for my loving mother and mum-in-law who stay with me in my thoughts even though they are no longer physically here.
  • Thankful for my great friends, both near and far away. Friends I can count on for fun times and for help in times of need.
  • Thankful for smart and hard-working colleagues at a university that really cares about students.
  • Thankful for my church and caring pastors who keep the real messages of Christianity in the forefront.
  • Thankful for the wonderful community of Kearney, Nebraska, that is full of great people and places. A special Thanksgiving shout-out to The World Theatre and all their volunteers who help make Kearney such a great place.

It is all too easy to focus on what is wrong with our troubled world. But for today I am thankful for all that is fabulous in it.

Happy Thanksgiving to you, one and all.

What are you thankful for?

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on I am thankful…

Guest Blog Post: How Ticketmaster Failed Us and Taylor Swift

Let me start by saying I’m not a Swiftie. I’ve listened to her Folklore album a time or two and viewed her Tiny Desk concert. That’s about it. I first learned about all of the fuss about how Ticketmaster was grossly mishandling the presale of Swift’s concert tickets from a blog post from one of my students last week. I then saw a tweet from PR guru and Twitter friend Kenna Griffin:

My first thought was: I’ve got to try to get Dr. Kenna to do a blog post on the absolute PR disaster Ticketmaster was having with the thousands of unhappy Taylor Swift fans. I was delighted when she said “Yes”!

It also turns out she was one of that crowd of disappointed fans who had presale codes but weren’t able to get tix.

Thanks, Dr. Kenna!


Guest Blog Post
By Dr. Kenna Griffin

It’s Ticketmaster. They’re the antihero, serving up a lesson in how not to run a business.

Taylor Swift The Eras Tour with multiple photos of TSIf you aren’t sure what I’m talking about, then you haven’t yet been one of the thousands of Taylor Swift fans held hostage by the website while trying to get tickets for the Eras Tour. It’s an experience that caused them and Swift, by proxy, a load of negative PR in the past week.

My Ticketmaster Story

My husband deserves a better wife. I came to this conclusion after he waited online for more than six hours to get me Taylor Swift tickets. We didn’t buy tickets in the end.

I, probably like many others, acted with excitement instead of logic when Taylor announced her Eras Tour. I immediately texted my bestie, and we picked out three locations each to try to get approved for. I was ecstatic when I got the email that I was approved for presale. She wasn’t approved. Still, we were stoked about an hour later when I got the text that we had a chance to get tickets for the Kansas City show. KC is within driving distance, meaning we could avoid airfare and budget a bit more for tickets.

Then the drama began. One of us needed to log in to my account at 10 a.m. Wednesday. The problem was that I was presenting a webinar at that time, and my physician friend had patients scheduled. There was no way we could log on until at least 11 a.m. We knew the tickets would be gone by then. Enter my fabulous husband.

He agreed to go online at 10 a.m. and do his best.

Six… hours… later…

The Ticketmaster site repeatedly crashed, leaving people less than thrilled. Ticketmaster sent a few pop-up messages to those waiting online, but they basically just said, “keep waiting, don’t refresh.”

My husband gave up and closed the site at the end of his work day. Then, out of curiosity, he logged back on just to see if he could get in. Yep. He got in immediately. Too bad the only tickets left were at the top of the stadium or behind the stage.

What an epic waste of time!

The PR Nightmare

You’ve likely already heard that we weren’t the only ones who had problems getting tickets. People took to social media with a lot to say about Ticketmaster, their monopoly, and even T. Swift in some cases. Take a look:

Tweet: Almost fur hurs. 2000+ in the queue before me. What a mess. It's like you're new at this?

Tweet - If anyone wonders why monopolies are bad, look no further than the epic fumble of Ticketmaster and the taylorswift13 presale. Ticketmaster has no competition, and thus they're allowed to keep sucking and also charging users insane fees for the pleasure.

Tweet from HuffPost. “Break them up,” the New York Democrat (AOC) urged.

Tweet - I wold like Taylor Swift herselft to try to get tickets to her own show.

Ticketmaster’s response to the whole debacle looked like this:

Response from Ticketmaster to users. Lots of demand, lots of tickets sold, keep waiting in the queue, a few more details.

Needless to say, fans weren’t having it.

Tweet - me trying to figure out how ticketmaster wasn't prepared for the demand for Taylor Swift tickets when they sent out the codes themselves to control a certain amount of people entering the presale #TheErasTour

Some fans even called for a do-over.

Tweet - Can Taylor Swift fans have a redo on tickets sales? Ticketmaster clearly wasn't prepared for this amount of traffic, and all verified fans with actual presale codes are unable to buy tickets. The site has done nothing but crash.

But many people got tickets, and they’re justifiably thrilled, even though they clearly didn’t enjoy the process.

Tweet - the lucky ones: i got in and got tickets to arlington taylor swift! me and all the others waiting in the broken queue
And how did Taylor respond? After all, it’s her reputation and the full Swiftie experience on the line.

I haven’t seen a thing at the time of writing this post. Nothing. Not a word.

And I’m not the only person less than happy about that.

Tweet - do we think taylor is gonna say anything about this or she gonna be like WOW you guys broke ticketmaster!!!! i cant wait to see you!!!!

What Can We Learn?

As the negative publicity continues rolling in and mainstream media are covering the story of the Taylor Swift/Ticketmaster fail, what can we learn from a PR perspective from this situation?

Remember that we’re talking about PR, so we can’t just say that Ticketmaster should know how to do its job. That’s a given.

I have some suggestions:

  • Communicate better in the process leading up to presale. Ticketmaster gave many instructions that day, probably because the entire process was confusing. So, ticket seekers went into the whole mess confused from the beginning.
  • Be transparent about pricing. I hate this part of the process. You don’t know if you’ll get tickets, and you have no idea how much they’ll be when you get there. What if people waited all day to get on the site only to find that they couldn’t afford the VIP tickets that were left?
  • Respond immediately and often. When things went haywire, Ticketmaster should have immediately started communicating what THEY were doing to solve the issues, not what fans needed to do (sit on their computers all day and wait).
  • Waive fees (or at least some of them). Ticketmaster is known for tacking fees onto tickets. It’s how they make their money. But when you’re failing at your side of the process, you need to let people know that you’re going to discount or waive those fees.
  • Apologize. Ticketmaster should have apologized every step of the way and should still be apologizing.

And as for T. Swift, recognize that you aren’t too big to fail. She should already have communicated with her fans how sorry she was that the process didn’t go the way it was supposed to. And she should be telling them if she plans to do something different with future tours. Remaining silent makes her look like she’s OK with it.

What do you think? What PR lessons can we learn from this? Comment below.


Dr. Kenna Griffin

Dr. Kenna Griffin

Dr. Kenna Griffin has been a writer, editor, and educator for more than two decades. She is a self-proclaimed word nerd.

Griffin is the content director for Content Journey. She also is an adjunct journalism and public relations professor. She was a full-time professor and college media adviser for nearly two decades, following a career as a professional journalist.

Griffin has a Ph.D. in journalism from the University of Oklahoma. She researches the relationship between emotional trauma, journalism professionalism, and organizational support.

Contact Dr. Kenna Griffin

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Guest Blog Post: How Ticketmaster Failed Us and Taylor Swift

How do journalists cover elections & Trump this time around?

I’ve been writing lately about how journalists covered the 2022 election. Is it too early to start thinking about the 2024 election? Even if it is, lots of journalists have started doing so. Let’s take a look:


Center right WaPo columnist and blogger Jennifer Rubin writes that reporters need to reconsider who they talk to and represent as typical voters, and what their approach should be to covering elections.

She writes:

“The media need to recognize that “Latino” is almost meaningless because it encompasses people with vastly different backgrounds, experiences and perspectives. Treating an American born in Puerto Rico like a third-generation businessman with a Spanish surname but no Spanish fluency makes little sense….

“A shift away from horserace coverage, which is often wrong and utterly irrelevant, would allow the media to focus on candidates’ experience and character, major policy issues and voters’ attitudes and demographic changes. Journalism should not be a Magic Eight Ball; it is about understanding and analyzing the recent past and present….

“Find gurus in each state who really understand the ins and outs of voting trends (e.g., Jon Ralston in Nevada), expand use of focus groups, track coverage in local media and watch where candidates are spending money…

“Journalism can improve its image by leaving the prognostication to betting markets and tarot card readers. That should free up resources to focus on the threats still facing democracy.”


During the 2016 and 2020 campaign, journalists and news media gave former president Donald Trump lots and lots of coverage compared to other candidates because he was constantly doing things that would attract audiences. It’s not that he was doing politically important things – he was just being clickable.

Now that he has officially declared himself as a candidate for the 2024 presidential election, journalists are going to have to figure out how they are going to report on a candidate who thrives on attention and who has a willingness to say anything, regardless of it’s truth value.

Not surprisingly, this has drawn a lot of attention from journalists and media critics on Twitter over the last day or two.


NYU journalism professor Dr. Jay Rosen has long been critical of how most journalists cover politicians and candidates. To me, his most important critique has been how reporters simply parrot back what politicians say without putting it in any context, especially when the politician is clearly lying. I really like how he explains that reporters need to be putting forward a “truth sandwich.”

Rosen explains the “truth sandwich” this way:

  1. State what is true.
  2. Report that a false or dubious claim has been made. (But only if it’s newsworthy, meaning important for the public to know it happened. Otherwise use silence.)
  3. Repeat what the actual truth is.

We saw the truth sandwich being applied (and not applied) by a number of prominent news outlets.


NPR on Twitter went all in on the truth sandwich with their story announcing Trump’s candidacy:

That 100% accurate headline nevertheless managed to draw huge howling charges of bias.


Law Dork Chris Geidner had praise for how the Washington Post presented the story in a news alert but was not as impressed with the aggressively neutral approach of the NY Times.

Washinton Post headline: Trump, who as president fomented an insurrection, says his is running again in 2024.

NY Times headline: Donald Trump announced a 2024 fun for president, ignoring GOP warnings that his influence is harming the party.


Oddly enough, the news outlet that gave Trump the hardest burn the conservative Rupert Murdoch tabloid the New York Post who put the story at the bottom of their cover and left out the former president’s name.

NY Post cover: Florida Man Makes Announcement, Page 26

The page 26 story was equally dismissive:

Though to be fair the online version of the story was much more complete, but still nasty in tone.


I look forward to seeing how news outlets and journalists cover Trump’s campaign going forward.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on How do journalists cover elections & Trump this time around?

Improving election coverage – Reflections on Election Day 2022 – Part 2

I’m not one to hammer on “THE MEDIA,” whatever that may be, but I do think there are things that journalists can do to improve their coverage of elections.:

I agree with Jerry here. This is so important. Journalists have got to get away from “who-is-winning-and-losing-horse-race” coverage and get down with the hard work of reporting on who these candidates are and what they stand for. And, yes, we will have to deal with being charged with “being biased” when we write about issues.

Journalists have to just get over their fear of being called “biased.” Journalists – critics / politicians / voters are never going to love you.  They will always be pushing that anything that does not match their desires is biased.

(There is also concern among reporters that audiences, based on social media clicks, really prefer horse race coverage over complex issue oriented reporting — tl:dr.)


One of the big problems with horse race journalism is that it is getting harder and harder to know who is ahead, especially in close races.

It seems like every election cycle we go through, there continues to be more and more concern about the accuracy of the polls. There are at least a couple of reasons for this.

  • We are having closer and closer elections. The polls can be accurate within their margin of error and still not give us very useful specific details.
  • It’s getting harder and harder to reach an accurate sample of the population as a whole.

There is also evidence that there is actually nothing wrong with the polls this election cycle. Perhaps there is just too much bad reporting based on polls:

 


Smart post from one of my commentary students:

You may or may not know that I’m located in central Nebraska, a state viewed as reliably Republican. Except we split our electoral votes by district and gave one vote to Biden in 2020.  Journalists have been surprised by how states like Kansas have been voting. It might be worthwhile to pay more attention to what “flyover” states are thinking. Other than talking old folks in diners…


Another thing that journalists have got to do is stop treating Hispanic voters as a uniform block. Folks whose families came from Cuba are different from those who came from Central America are different from those who came from South America. Those who are wealthy business people are different from those who work for hourly wages. There are lots of differences within this population. Don’t imagine one ethic group is uniform in their political values.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Improving election coverage – Reflections on Election Day 2022 – Part 2

Reflections on Election Day 2022 News Coverage – Part 1

Election Day 2022 went remarkably smoothly. There are still a number of uncalled contests, most notably three US senate races as of this writing mid-afternoon on Thursday, Nov. 10.

But so far it appears that people were able to reliably vote, the votes were tabulated without controversy, and the candidates who lost conceded with more or less dignity.  (Though a couple of high profile races involving 2020 election deniers have yet to be called.  We may yet have STOP THE STEAL screaming to come.)

Here are a few reflections about this election cycle now that it’s a couple days after the battle. I hope to have a few more that deal with how journalists cover elections in the next day or two.


MSNBC is not the Fox News of the left

There is no question that MSNBC is a progressive, left-leaning network. But that does not make it the mirror image of the right-wing commentary network Fox News.

Fox News is primarily a talk show network (not a criticism, just look at their programming), and their talk programming bears little concern about anything other than conservative talking points.

MSNBC takes a left-leaning stand in what is good or bad, but is absolutely willing to be critical of progressives.


But when Fox News gets into their polling operation and election results analysis, they actually are a good news outlet.

In fact, the Fox News opinion hosts and guests often get quite irate with the Decision Desk on election nights. Their polling and election calling departments do good work based on the best information.


Tired Journalists Dept.

It’s easy to make fun of dumb things journalists say after a long night on TV or radio, and we should cut them some slack. But I really did love this one…


“I Was Wrong…”

It seems like the rarest thing in news and commentary is to hear an opinion writer admit that they were wrong after completely screwing up a prediction. There were lots of bad predictions about Tuesday’s elections where commentators had been solemnly predicting a large-scale GOP victory that never materialized.

Props to WaPo columnist Henry Olsen for admitting he was wrong and explaining why.

On an entirely separate issue, WaPo media critic Erik Wemple (already cited earlier in this commentary) also apologized for his ill-founded criticism of former NY Times opinion editor James Bennet.


And finally, in the realm of really tacky (but funny) media criticism…

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Reflections on Election Day 2022 News Coverage – Part 1