Reposting – Questioning The Hunger Games

Last evening I went to see the movie Catching Fire, the sequel to The Hunger Games with students in my media literacy class.  As you all no doubt know, Suzanne Collins wrote the hugely successful young adult three-volume series that tells the story of a young woman forced to fight to the death with other teens in a televised arena.  The series sold more than 9.6 million copies even before the first movie based on the books was released.  Both Catching Fire and The Hunger Games have been made into top grossing movies as well.  In case you are interested, here is what I wrote about The Hunger Games back in April of 2012.

So the movie of The Hunger Games is out, and it’s been an enormous success.  Here are some questions the movie might raise:

Posted in Chapter 4, Chapter 8 | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Reposting – Questioning The Hunger Games

Lesson of the Day: Don’t Photoshop details out of news photos

A photographer for the Charleston (WV) Gazette learned a difficult lesson that really shouldn’t have to be learned: Don’t Photoshop details out of a news photo.  Just don’t.

I got a note from a former student of mine who is a West Virginia journalist that there was a big controversy going on online in Charleston over the photo that ran on the front page of today’s Gazette to go with a story about a former magistrate pleading guilty to voter-registration fraud.

The photo, posted to Twitter by West Virginia radio personality Hoppy Kercheval, shows the image of a WOWK-TV microphone with the station’s logo blurred out:

Altered photo from Charleston Gazette

Later this morning, the Charleston Gazette published an apology to Facebook, along with the unaltered image:

A Gazette photographer went outside the boundaries of our standards when he obscured the name of a television station on a microphone in today’s front-page photo. Other than the photographer, no one at the Gazette was aware of what had taken place with the photo. Our photographers know that it is unacceptable to alter reality in news photos. The photographer believed his action helped direct the focus of the photo to the subject. He was wrong to do so. This is a singular incident. Disciplinary action will be taken to ensure it doesn’t happen again.
(Attached is a copy of the photo as it should have appeared.)

This is quite a bit smaller of a change than that done by The Dominion Post (in Morgantown, WV) back in 2010 when an editor removed several people from an official photo from the governor’s office. The funny thing with that case was that there was no need for the editor to have done any Photoshopping as the governor’s office had exactly the photo that paper would have liked to have had, if they had only asked for it.

Posted in Chapter 14 | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

Link Ch. 7 – Cover versions can transform songs: Robyn’s “Call Your Girlfriend”

UPDATE: Want to see another great original and cover? Check out Dolly Parton and Whitney Houston doing their own versions of Parton’s “I’ll Always Love You.”

I had not heard of the pop singer Robyn until recently when podcaster Brian Ibbott did an episode of Coverville devoted to her.  I enjoyed the show back when it streamed in mid-September, but I was reminded of it when I heard singer/songwriter Lucy Wainright Roche perform a version of Robyn’s hit “Call Your Girlfriend” on Mountain Stage’s 30th Anniversary show.

(Mountain Stage is a live-music show produced by West Virginia Public Radio for the last 30 years.  It has featured country, indie, roots, and just about every other kind of music over the years. If you ever get the chance to attend a recording of the show, do so!)

In this cover, Lucy Wainright Roche transforms Robyn’s upbeat pop song into a sorrowful ballad and completely changes the feel of the song.  I’ve heard more transformative parody covers, but rarely have I heard a “serious” cover that so completely changes not just the feel but the actual meaning of a song.

So… Here’s the original Robyn pop version of “Call Your Girlfriend”:

And here’s Lucy Wainright Roche’s brilliant cover:

UPDATE: And just for fun, here are Lennon and Maisy from the show Nashville doing their version “Call Your Girlfriend.” Thanks to my student Erin Cuddy for the link.

 

Posted in Book Link, Chapter 7 | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Link Ch. 7 – Cover versions can transform songs: Robyn’s “Call Your Girlfriend”

Katie Couric leaves “mainstream media” for…. mainstream media?

You would be hard pressed to find anyone in the media business more mainstream that news anchor/personality Katie Couric.  She represents everything that characterizes legacy media.  She’s had interviews with all the big stars from Hollywood to D.C. She’s a perky and likable guest we’re happy to bring into our house on a daily basis through the morning or evening television news.

If you talk about the mainstream media, you’re talking about folks like Ms. Couric.

And yet… earlier this week she announced that she was leaving ABC television to become the “global news anchor” for Yahoo! News.  And so the big news is that Katie is leaving the Mainstream Media for the brave new world of online media!

Except….

As commentary and news site The Daily Beast points out:

  • Yahoo and ABC are partners in a news site.
  • Yahoo/ABC reaches 800 million people per month.
  • Yahoo News was seen by 10 million people on election night 2012.
  • Couric is joining other big name journalists at Yahoo News, including Matt Bai, New York Times Magazine political correspondent; David Pogue, legendary NY Times technology columnist; and Megan Liberman, deputy editor of the NY Times.

Of course, exactly what Katie Couric is going to be doing for Yahoo isn’t completely clear yet.  But according to an interview with Ad Age magazine, she will be doing video interviews and… “things that might be more appropriate for mobile devices…”  In other words, she’s bringing her star power to Yahoo to help it be recognized as the mainstream power that it is.

This is a great example of Truth #2 – There are no Mainstream Media.

We have legacy media.

We have big media.

We have independent media.

We have liberal media.

We have conservative media.

We have corporate media.

But I don’t know what would constitute mainstream media.  Anything that can draw 10 million pairs of eyeballs on one night seems no less mainstream than something that’s been around for 70 or 80 years.

Posted in Chapter 1, Chapter 10, Chapter 9 | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Katie Couric leaves “mainstream media” for…. mainstream media?

Questions Worth Asking (Maybe)

Posted in Chapter 10, Chapter 15, Chapter 6 | Tagged , , , , , , | Comments Off on Questions Worth Asking (Maybe)

A few hints for radio storytelling

My students in my interpretive reporting class are going to be hosting an hour-long radio program to talk about the stories they are doing about the role of the international community at UNK.  Here are a few links that can help with a wide range of radio storytelling:

Posted in Chapter 7 | Tagged , | Comments Off on A few hints for radio storytelling

The Weight Loss Secret The Media Won’t Tell You!

Julia Kozerski - Before and AfterNo, this isn’t about how to lose 20 pounds while eating hot fudge sundaes.

And it’s not about the cabbage soup diet.

And it’s not about how eating the right kinds of proteins will “burn your fat.”

(Really, there aren’t any secrets on how to lose weight, no matter what “they” say, with the possible exception of the Bloom County Diet (“How about eating less and exercise.”). And even that is no guarantee.

No, the weight loss secret the media won’t tell you is that losing weight, lots of weight, will not necessarily give you a happily ever after life.

Actually, that’s a lie, because I was told that story today by “the media” with an article by Alexandria Symonds writing for New York Magazine.  Symonds writes about the work by photographer Julia Kozerski who documented her own loss of 160 pounds through her photo series Changing Room and Half. (Please note that Kozerski’s projects contain nudity. Click on the photo above to go to Julia’s Facebook page.)

As Symonds points out, Kozerski clearly is pleased by much of what she sees with her weight loss, but she is also moved to tears by her “stretch marks, loose skin, stretched navel, sagging breasts.” In short, Kozerski’s experience was not that which was sold to her by magazines, television shows, and diet-industry ads.  As an example, Symonds notes that People magazine retouches or strategically hides the stretch marks and loose skin in their weight loss issue.

I really liked the conclusion of Symond’s article about the misperceptions of how massive weight loss will affect your life:

The most important thing, though, is to stop allowing ourselves to be told that everything would be different if we could just lose the weight.  Bit, important things about people’s lives do change after they’ve lost weight — and yes, often for the better — but no one becomes a different person.  You’re still you, even when you’re half of your former self.

Symond’s article and Kozerski’s photos are worth spending time with as an alternative approach to analyzing the stories our media tell about weight loss and body image. They tell a complex story that moves beyond “loving yourself the way you are” and “losing weight will solve all your problems.”

Posted in Chapter 5 | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

Questions Worth Asking (Maybe)

Posted in Chapter 10, Chapter 12, Chapter 5, Chapter 7, Chapter 9 | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Questions Worth Asking (Maybe)

What is the Internet?

What is the Internet?

Last week I asked my Global Media Literacy students what television was.  And the discussion was so much fun, I thought I would try it again this week.

So what is the Internet? In some ways, I think my students had a much better handle on what is the Internet than on what is television.

The first response to the question was “search engine,” and by “search engine” my student meant Google.  I asked them if they ever used any other search engine, like Microsoft’s Bing.  And another student spoke up proclaiming, “I hate it when a page tries to make you use Bing!”

I can think of worse definitions of the Internet than things that Google does.

I also got several responses that dealt with it being:

  • a network
  • not a physical thing
  • can’t touch it
  • a series of data sequences

But perhaps the most perceptive response was: Without it my computer’s useless!

Posted in Chapter 10 | Tagged , , | Comments Off on What is the Internet?

Link Ch. 9 – What Is Television?

(Before we get started, I know I misspelled satellite on the white board this morning.  Get over it…)

This morning in my Global Media Literacy class I asked my students a fairly simple question: What is television?

The answers that came back were revealing, to say the least — a fascinating collection of both the retro and the ultra-modern.

As you can see by the white board photo, the very first word that came to mind was “Box.” And by box, my student meant the big, old-style analog TV with a big ol’ picture tube.  Literally, a giant box. But I think that’s informative – Television is seen as a device for consuming video from wherever it comes from.

After that came a couple of more use-based terms – Entertainment and Reruns.

But then came the one that really grabbed my attention:

“Moving pictures that you stream.”

And following that came the local cable company and satellite providers.

I don’t know that the student who said “stream” was really talking about Internet streaming; more likely, I think she was just talking about content that streamed in an unending flow to the television box.

Broadcasting didn’t get mentioned until one young lady Googled “television” and came up with the term broadcasting.

This launched us into a discussion of the history of television, moving from analog to digital, black & white to color, and the rise of alternatives to broadcast television.  But what it came down to was that these young people saw radio as something that comes in over the airwaves.

This highlights what I think is a really important issue to think about – the young people in my class don’t distinguish between broadcast and cable/satellite channels.  We have all sorts of legal distinctions between broadcast and cable/satellite, and even online streaming services.  But to this group of young people, they’re all just television.

And that’s something we need understand going forward.

Posted in Book Link, Chapter 9 | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment