Is Carnival cruising for a PR bruising?

Carnival's Twitter feed from 2/15/13

Carnival’s Twitter feed from 2/15/13

Updated

By now, virtually everyone in America knows about the mess that is the Carnival cruise ship Triumph.  The ship suffered an engine fire earlier this week that resulted in the ship being without electricity and drifting in the Gulf of Mexico.  The stories coming out of the Triumph were pretty ugly.  Raw sewage was reportedly seeping down walls, food was scarce, air conditioning was out, the ship was wallowing in heaving seas, and people were definitely not having a good time. The LA Times wrote that the cruise was a cross between television’s Survivor and the novel Lord of the Flies.

Then on Thursday, as the ship was under tow to port in Mobile, Alabama, CNN started doing wall-to-wall coverage of the “cruise from hell.” And passengers have not been shy about sharing their feelings via cell phones on social media.

So for those of us living in the media world, the question we all need to ask is: How will Carnival respond and recover from this public relations mess/crisis/disaster?

Update: Michael Sebastian at Ragan’s PR Daily says that while Carnival had a few missteps, their overall PR efforts were good.
NOTE: If you want to know more about this story, NPR’s Mark Memmott has a good round-up blog post on the topic.

 

 

Posted in Chapter 12 | Tagged | 1 Comment

Comcast completing purchase of NBCUniversal from GE years ahead of schedule

The transition of NBCUniversal from being owned primarily by General Electric to Comcast had been expected to be an extended process, with the cable and phone giant gradually acquiring the entertainment company’s stock.  But that changed this week with the announcement that Comcast would be completing the purchase of NBCU by the end of March.

Amy Chozick and Brian Selter of the New York Times report a variety of reasons for the faster pace of the acquisition, including:

  • A conflict between the corporate cultures of Comcast and GE,
  • Comcast’s desire to control programming sources as well as channels for distribiution, and that
  • Now was financially a good time for Comcast to make the purchase.

Chozick and Selter report that:

The transaction made Comcast, the single biggest cable provider in the United States, one of the biggest owners of cable channels, too. NBCUniversal operates the NBC broadcast network, 10 local NBC stations, USA, Bravo, Syfy, E!, MSNBC, CNBC, the NBC Sports Network, Telemundo, Universal Pictures, Universal Studios, and a long list of other media brands.

 

Posted in Chapter 3, Chapter 9 | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Media News Roundup

Posted in Chapter 11, Chapter 3, Chapter 6 | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Media News Roundup

When news catches up with my long-term pop culture diet

I’ve been planning for several days to write a blog entry today about three movies from 1968 that I’ve watched over the last couple of weeks  – 2001: A Space Odyssey, Ice Station Zebra, and The Shoes of the Fisherman.

Why these movies?

When I was eight years old and growing up in Iowa, my parents took the whole family to the River Hills Theater in Des Moines to see 2001.  River Hills was a spectacular theater designed for Cinerama and 70mm films, featuring a 90-foot wide curved screen.  Sort of the commercial IMAX of the time.  In addition to being blown away by 2001, I was also impressed by the two trailers we saw – Ice Station Zebra and The Shoes of the Fisherman.  Even more than 45 years later, I still remember seeing both the movie and the trailers.  In fact, that evening helped set in motion my lifetime love of seeing bigger than life movies in big theaters.

A couple of weeks ago, I found Ice Station Zebra showing on Turner Classic movies, and that prompted me to go ahead a watch those three 1968 blockbusters.  I had, of course, seen 2001.  And I suspect, though I’m not certain, that I’ve seen all or most of Cold War submarine thriller Ice Station Zebra at one time or another.  But this was definitely my first time to see Shoes of the Fisherman.  The movie tells the story of a Ukrainian bishop who has been imprisoned in a Soviet gulag for 20 years.  He’s released in a deal with the Vatican to help prevent the outbreak of WW III between the Soviets and the Chinese.  In a strange turn of events, the Ukrainian bishop is quickly elevated from being a political prisoner to being the first non-Italian pope in centuries.

The movie holds up surprising well over the years, with a beautiful look at the papal election process and the role that our religious leaders can play in world events.

So I’ve been planning to blog about this 45-year-delay from seeing the trailer to seeing the movie, and then the news catches up with me with surprise announcement this morning that Pope Benedict XVI is resigning because of old age.  And in a strange coincidence, Turner Classic Movies already had two screenings of Shoes of the Fisherman scheduled over the next month.  Though it wouldn’t surprise me now if they move up and expand their showing of it.

At any rate, I highly recommend both 2001 and Shoes of the Fisherman.  Ice Station Zebra was fun, but largely dated.  If you decide to watch Shoes, try to catch it on TCM.  The print available on DVD is pretty bad.  Here are the trailers for these three movies:

Shoes of the Fisherman

2001: A Space Odyssey

Ice Station Zebra

Posted in Chapter 8, Uncategorized | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Amazing Media Quotes

A round up of unexpected things I’ve read recently.  None of these are from The Onion!

  • NPR Station Urges Listeners to Have Sex and Make More Listeners
    “Chicago’s NPR station, WBEZ, is making a more intimate appeal than usual during its current membership drive. Rather than simply asking you for a few bucks, the station is asking you to “Go make babies” with other “interesting people”—who may be likely to become “interesting people” and future WBEZ listeners themselves.” (AdWeek, HT @ojezap)
  • Why Red State’s Erick Erickson is an interesting addition to Fox News
    “We no longer have to transport ourselves to a magical alternate reality to ponder what a love child between Richard Nixon and Dick Cheney would look like.  Given a Justice Department memo obtained by NBC News, we can conclude that child would look like none other than President Barack Obama.” Erick Erickson of RedState.com and Fox News.
  • When social media PR goes bad – Applebee’s edition
    “One would think that in 2013 anyone who does social media professionally has the social Web figured out, particularly when one works for a big brand that has hundreds of thousands of customers who know how to use Facebook and Twitter.”But I guess we know what happens when one assumes.

    Let’s take Applebee’s as case in point.” (Ragan.com)

  • We’re really living in a mobile media world
    “By 2017, there will be an estimated 5.2 billion people using mobile phones, up from 4.3 billion in 2012. There will also be about 1.7 billion connected machines — anything from a home appliance to a car — in five years.” (Cecilia Kang, Washington Post)
Posted in Chapter 10, Chapter 12, Chapter 7, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Amazing Media Quotes

Free Kindle download on book about Disney’s John Carter of Mars misfire

“John Carter and the Gods of Hollywood” about what went wrong with the Disney/Andrew Stanton adaptation of John Carter of Mars is free on Kindle through Thursday, February 7th.

Thanks to BoingBoing for the story on this.

 

Posted in Chapter 8 | Tagged , | Comments Off on Free Kindle download on book about Disney’s John Carter of Mars misfire

Why I’m Bored With Super Bowl Ads

It pains me to say this, but I’m bored with Super Bowl advertising. Instead of being innovative, exciting, new and different, they mostly have a predictable sameness to them. This supercut of Super Bowl ads posted over at Deadspin highlights the problem of “How many boobs and nut shots were there in the Super Bowl commercials?”  As they say:

Another year, another 70-plus multimillion-dollar round of hyper-produced spots for the Super Bowl featuring silent women in bikinis, abused consumers, and CrAzY CoLLiSiOns. May we never forget the two magic words—sex and violence—and may we never evolve.

To be sure, there were memorable, heart touching ads out there.  Dodge had the 2-minute-long “So God made a farmer” Paul Harvey-voiced ad for their trucks which attracted mixed response, depending, I suppose, on what part of the country you’re from.  (I live in Nebraska and liked it, though I don’t think it was as good as the Eminem “Imported From Detroit” ad from a couple of years ago):

Another ad that attracted a lot of positive attention (and romanticized farming) was the Budweiser ad featuring a newborn clydesdale. It was USA Today’s highest rated commercial of the evening, and the clydesdales have long history as part of the Budweiser brand image. (The version I’ve linked to is an extended web-cut of the ad.)

(Ok, after rewatching this one, I have to admit it’s a heartwarming ad that does a lot to build good feelings about the brand.)

But overall, I can’t say that any of the ads this year stood out as giving a strong message positive message about the product as well as being enjoyable to watch.  Yes, I liked the Paul Harvey-based Dodge ad.  But I would have been hard pressed to know that it was an ad for Dodge trucks.  Instead, I’m going to remember the great short film about farmers.

Argue as much as you want about the Eminem Imported From Detroit playing fast and loose with labor history, it made me proud of Chrysler, even if I shouldn’t have been.

And that’s what I think makes for a great commercial.

Posted in Chapter 11 | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Why I’m Bored With Super Bowl Ads

Oreo’s social media blackout ad was hit of 2013 Super Bowl

When the lights went out on the Super Bowl Sunday, Raven’s coach John Harbaugh looked a bit upset about his team losing its momentum.  And the big advertisers like Coke and and Pepsi didn’t like having their carefully planned series of ads disrupted.

For me, though the big deal to come out of half-hour lights out delay was the fact that Oreo was able to execute, approve and deliver a brilliant little social media ad within minutes of the outage starting.

As Ad Age reports, other advertisers also jumped in, but few did it as well as Oreo did.  They note that Oreo’s agency put together the creative (the image) and got it approved within minutes.  And once it was out there, people retweeted the message more than 10,000 times within an hour.  Ad Age was arguing on Monday that Oreo got a bigger bang out of this simple message that the cookie company did out of its elaborate (and expensive) TV commercial.

To me, this commercial represents everything that’s wrong with Super Bowl commercials these days.  They work so hard at giving us something exciting and fun to watch that they forget to tell us anything about the brand.  The TV ad is funny, but the lights out quickie ad made me want cookies and milk.

Posted in Chapter 11 | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

When Super Bowls Turn Naughty – Do We Care?

During the 2004 Super Bowl, singer Janet Jackson exposed her nipple for 9/16ths of a second, resulting in 8 years of litigation over whether CBS would have to pay a $500,000 fine for the “fleeting nudity.”  In the end, courts ruled that the proposed fine was “arbitrary and capricious.”

Want to make up your own mind?  Here’s the section of the halftime show in question:

(Of course, when Nancy Grace did the same thing on Dancing with the Stars, no one talked about fines….)

Then this year immediately following the Super Bowl, Ravens player Joe Flacco drops the  F-bomb, calling the game ” F&$%ing awesome” in front of a live microphone.  Again, a fleeting offensive moment that could potentially lead to substantial fines.

This morning, I asked the students in my Global Media Literacy class how they felt about both Jackson and Flacco. The question was: Are you more bothered by Jackson’s 9/16ths of a second exposure, Flacco’s F-bomb, or are you unable to get upset about either.  Here’s the results:

  • Jackson – 4
  • Flacco – 1
  • Don’t care about either – 16

And this is in central Nebraska.  FCC, perhaps there are better things for you to worry about these days.

Posted in Chapter 1, Chapter 3, Chapter 9, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

AV Club on why Mr. Rogers was greatest TV show ever

“In its low-rent production values and matter-of-fact delivery, Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood got at something simple, yet surprisingly profound: People just want to be loved.” – Todd VanDerWerff

Couldn’t agree more!  Mr. Rogers always had the joy of simple things in everything  he did.

Mr.Rogers on the Tonight Show in 1983

Posted in Chapter 9 | Tagged , | Comments Off on AV Club on why Mr. Rogers was greatest TV show ever